I thought this year I'd have a crack at this ratings thread. I'll give each episode either an A, B, C, D or F and a season average (which may include + or -).

Damages: A-
Pilot: A
Jesus, Mary and Joe ****er: A
And My Paralyzing Fear of Death: A
Tastes Like a Ho Ho: B
A Regular Earl Attorney: C
She Spat at Me: B
We Are Not Animals: B
Blame the Victim: A
Do You Regret What We Did?: A
Sort of Like a Family: A
I Hate These People: A
There's No 'We' Anymore: A
Because I Know Patty: A

Heroes: C-
Chapter One: Four Months Later: D
Chapter Two: Lizards: D
Chapter Three: Kindred: D
Chapter Four: The Kindness of Strangers: D
Chapter Five: Fight or Flight: D
Chapter Six: The Line: D
Chapter Seven: Out of Time: C
Chapter Eight: Four Months Ago: C
Chapter Nine: Cautionary Tales: A

House: B
Alone: C
The Right Stuff: B
97 Seconds: A
Guardian Angels: B
Mirror, Mirror: B
Whatever It Takes: A
Ugly: B
You Don't Want to Know: A

My Name Is Earl: D+
My Name Is Inmate 28301-016 (part 2): C
The Frank Factor: C
Frank's Girl: F

Prison Break: C+
Orientation: C
Fire/Water: C
Call Waiting: D
Good Fences: B
Interference: B
Photo Finish: C
Vamonos: B
Bang and Burn: A

This message has been edited. Last edited by: Noble,

Updated my list on Page 03 with the second and third episodes of Pushing Daisies.

SUNDAY
Desperate Housewives
4.01: "Now You Know" B+ MVP: Marcia Cross
4.02: "Smiles of a Summer Night" B MVP: Marcia Cross
4.03: "The Game" A MVP: Teri Hatcher
4.04: "If There's Anything I Can't Stand" B+ MVP: Marcia Cross
4.05: "Art Isn't Easy" B+ MVP: Felicity Huffman
4.06: "Now I Know, Don't Be Scared" A- MVP: Teri Hatcher

Brothers & Sisters
2.01: "Home Front" B- MVP: Field
2.02: "An American Family" B MVP/FYC: Field and Annable
2.03: "History Repeating" B- MVP: Field
2.04: "States of the Union" B-
2.05: "Domestic Issues" B- MVP/FYC: Griffiths
2.06: "Two Places" C+

Dexter
2.01: "It's Alive" B+
2.02: "Waiting To Exhale" B
2.03: "An Inconvenient Lie" B+
2.04: "See-Through" B-
2.05: "The Dark Defender" B+ FYC: Hall
2.06: "Dex, Lies & Videotape" B+

MONDAY
The Closer
3.01: "Homewrecker" A FYC: Sedgwick
3.02: "Grave Doubts" B+
3.03: "Saving Face" A-
3.04: "Ruby" A FYC: Sedgwick, Freeman, Series
3.05: "The Round File" B-
3.06: "Dumb Luck" A-
3.07: "Four to Eight" C+
3.08: "Manhunt" A FYC: Sedgwick
3.09: "Blindsided" A FYC: Sedgwick
3.10: "Culture Shock" C+
3.11: "Lover's Leap" B-
3.12: "Til Death Do us Part (Part One)" B
3.13: "Til Death Do Us Part (Part Two)" B
3.14: "Next of Kin (Part One)"
3.15: "Next of Kin (Part Two)"

Chuck
1.01: "Pilot" B
1.02: "Chuck Versus the Helicopter" B-
1.03: "Chuck Versus the Tango" A-
1.04: "Chuck Versus the Wookie" B-
1.05: "Chuck Versus the Sizzling Shrimp" C+
1.06: "Chuck Versus the Sandworm" B
1.07: "Chuck Versus the Alma Mater" A-

Heroes
2.01: "Four Months Later" C
2.02: "Lizards" C+
2.03: "Kindred" B-
2.04: "The Kindness of Strangers" B-
2.05: "Fight or Flight" B-
2.06: "The Line" C+
2.07: "Out of Time"

TUESDAY
Boston Legal
4.01: "Beauty and the Beast" B+
4.02: "The Innocent Man" B-
4.03: "The Chicken and the Leg" A- MVP/FYC: Spader
4.04: "Do Tell" A- MVP/FYC: Bergen
4.05: "Hope and Gory" A-
4.06: "The Object of My Affection"

Law & Order: Special Victims Unit
9.01: "Alternate" B
9.02: "Avatar" C-
9.03: "Impulsive" B+
9.04: "Savant" B-
9.05: "Harm"
9.06: "Svengali"

WEDNESDAY
Pushing Daises
1.01: "Pie-lette" B+
1.02: "Dummy" B
1.03: "The Fun in Funeral" B+
1.04: "Pigeon" B+
1.05: "Girth" B

Private Practice
1.01: "Pilot/In Which We Meet Addison" B MVP: Brenneman
1.02: "In Which Sam Receives An Unexpected Visitor" B-
1.03: "In Which Addison Finds The Magic" C+
1.04: "In Which Addison Has A Casual Get Together" A-
1.05: "In Which Addison Finds A Showerhead" A-
1.06: "In Which Charlotte Goes Down the Rabbit Hole" B

Dirty Sexy Money
1.01: "Pilot" B MVP: Krause
1.02: "The Lions" A- MVP/FYC: Clayburgh
1.03: "The Italian Banker" C+ MVP:
1.04: "The Chiavennasca" B+ MVP: Sutherland, Clayburgh
1.05: "The Bridge" B-
1.06: "The Game" B-

THURSDAY
Ugly Betty
2.01: "How Betty Got Her Grieve Back" B+ MVP: Ortiz, Light
2.02: "Family Affair" B-
2.03: "Betty's Wait Problem" C+
2.04: "Grin and Bear it" B-
2.05: "A League of Their Own" B-
2.06: "Something Wicked This Way Comes" C+

Grey's Anatomy
4.01: "A Change Is Gonna Come" C+
4.02: "Love/Addiction" B
4.03: "Let The Truth Sting" B-
4.04: "The Heart of the Matter" B+ MVP/FYC: Sara Ramirez
4.05: "Haunt You Everyday" B
2.06: "Kung Fu Fighting" C

30 Rock
2.01: "SeinfeldVision" B-
2.02: "Jack Gets in the Game" B+
2.03: "The Collection" B
2.04: "Rosemary's Baby" B+ MVP/FYC: Baldwin

It's Always Sunny in Philadelphia
3.01: "The Gang Finds a Dumpster Baby"
3.02: "The Gang Gets Invincible"
3.03: "Dennis and Dee's Mom is Dead" A MVP: Howerton, Devito
3.04: "The Gang Gets Held Hostage" A-
3.05: "The Aluminum Monster vs. Fatty McGoo" A MVP: Olson
3.06: "The Gang Solves the North Korea Situation" A-
3.07: "The Gang Sells Out" B+
3.08: "Frank Sets Sweet Dee On Fire" B+
3.09: "Sweet Dee's Dating a Retarded Person" A-
3.10: "Mac is a Serial Killer" B+
3.11: "Dennis Looks Like A Registered Sex Offender" B
2.12: "The Gang Gets Whacked" B

FRIDAY
Women's Murder Club
1.01: "Pilot/Welcome to the Club" B MVP: Harmon
1.02: "Train in Vain" B-
1.03: "Blind Dates and Bleeding Hearts" B-
1.04: "Grannies, Drugs & Love Mints" B-

This message has been edited. Last edited by: Pats12Fan,

sorry, didn't mean to post here

This message has been edited. Last edited by: Noble,

Added my viewing schedule on page 01.

Adding final grades to "Studio 60 on the Sunset Strip".

Final grades for "The Closer".

Adding final grades for "Big Love".

Desperate Housewives

4x01 Now You Know: A
MVP: Marcia Cross & Teri Hatcher FYC: M. Cross, T. Hatcher, series
4x02: Smiles of a Summer Night: B+
MVP: Dana Delany FYC: D. Delany, E. Longoria Parker
4x03: The Game: A+
MVP: Felicity Huffman FYC: F. Huffman, T. Hatcher, P. Bergen, D. Delany, series
4x04: If There's Anything I Can't Stand: B
MVP: Teri Hatcher FYC: S. Knight, T. Hatcher
4x05: Art Isn't Easy: A+
MVP: Marcia Cross
4x06: Now I Know, Don't Be Scared: A-
MVP: Felicity Huffman
4x07: You Can't Judge A Book By It's Cover: B
MVP: Eva Longoria Parker
4x08: Distant Past: B+
MVP: Teri Hatcher
4x09: Something's Coming: A+
MVP: Eva Longoria Parker FYC: E. Longoria Parker, N. Sheridan, K. Joosten
4x10: Welcome to Kanagawa: A
MVP: Marcia Cross FYC: M. Cross, K. Joosten
4x11: Sunday: B-
MVP: Eva Longoria Parker
4x12: In Buddy's Eyes: A+
MVP: Eva Longoria Parker FYC: series, D. Delany, E. Longoria Parker
4x13: Hello, Little Girl: A
MVP: Teri Hatcher
4x14 Opening Doors: A-
MVP: Dana Delany
4x15 Mother Said: A
MVP: Felicity Huffman
4x16 The Gun Song (1st part of season finale): A-
MVP: Eva Longoria Parker
4x17 Free (2nd part of season finale): A+
MVP: Dana Delany

Grade for Season 4: A
Season MVP: (tie) Eva Longoria Parker & Marcia Cross
Season Runner Up: Teri Hatcher

Best Comedy Series (The Game)
Best Actress in Comedy Series: Marcia Cross (Now You Know)
Best Actress in Comedy Series: Teri Hatcher (Now You Know)
Best Actress in Comedy Series: Felicity Huffman (The Game)
Best Actress in Comedy Series: Eva Longoria Parker (In Buddy's Eyes)
Supporting Actress in Comedy Series: Dana Delany (Smiles Of A Summer Night)
Supporting Actress in Comedy Series: Kathryn Joosten (Something's Coming)
Guest Actress in Comedy Series: Shirley Knight (If There's Anything I Can't Stand)
Guest Actress in Comedy Series: Polly Bergen (The Game)

Pushing Daisies
1x01 Pie-lette: A+
MVP: Lee Pace FYC: series, L. Pace
1x02 Dummy: A
MVP: Kristen Chenoweth FYC: K. Chenoweth
1x03 The Fun In Funeral: B+
MVP: Chi McBride
1x04 Pigeon: B
MVP: Lee Pace
1x05 Girth: A+
MVP: Kristen Chenoweth & Lee Pace
1x06 Bitches: A-
MVP: Chi McBride FYC: C. McBride
1x07 Smell Of Success: A-
MVP: Swoosie Kurtz & Ellen Greene
1x08 Bitter Sweets: B+
MVP: Anna Friel
1x09 Corpsicle: A
MVP: Anna Friel
Overall: Season Grade: A
Season MVP: Lee Pace
Season Runner Up: Kristen Chenoweth
Best Comedy Series (Pie-lette)
Best Actor in Comedy Series: Lee Pace (Pie-lette)
Supporting Actress in Comedy Series: Kristen Chenoweth (Girth)
Supporting Actor in Comedy Series: Chi McBride (Bitches)

FYC Primetime Emmys 2008: Desperate Housewives, Marcia Cross, Teri Hatcher, Shirley Knight, Dana Delany, Kathryn Joosten, Weeds, Elizabeth Perkins, Ugly Betty, Becki Newton, Michael Urie, Judith Light, Ana Ortiz, Vanessa Williams, Pushing Daisies, Lee Pace, Kristen Chenoweth, Brothers & Sisters, Calista Flockhart, Matthew Rhys, Rachel Griffiths, House, M.D, Hugh Laurie.

This message has been edited. Last edited by: Jake221,

Adding "Grey's Anatomy", "Dirty Sex Money", "Damages" and "Desperate Housewives" to my list of grades.

Damages (Season One)

Just finished the DVD. This was an amazing first season. I cannot wait for season two.

Glenn Close, Ted Danson, and Rose Byrne were all exceptional and the writing was great.

I hope it gets some major emmy love!

A

IN TREATMENT

1x01: Laura, Week One - B-
1x02: Alex, Week One - B
1x03: Sophie, Week One - B-
1x04: Jake and Amy, Week One - C+
1x05: Gina, Week One - B-
1x06: Laura, Week Two - B
1x07: Alex, Week Two - B
1x08: Sophie, Week Two - B+
1x09: Jake and Amy, Week Two - A-
1x10: Gina, Week Two - B
1x11: Laura, Week Three - C+
1x12: Alex, Week Three - B-
1x13: Sophie, Week Three - A
1x14: Jake and Amy, Week Three - B
1x15: Gina, Week Three - B+
1x16: Laura, Week Four - B-
1x17: Alex, Week Four - B-
1x18: Sophie, Week Four - A
1x19: Jake and Amy, Four - B+
1x20: Gina, Week Four - B
1x21: Laura, Week Five - B
1x22: Alex, Week Five - C+
1x23: Sophie, Week Five - A
1x24: Jake and Amy, Week Five - B+
1x25: Gina, Week Five - A-
1x26: Laura, Week Six - B+
1x27: Alex, Week Six - A
1x28: Sophie, Week Six - B
1x29: Jake and Amy, Week Six - A
1x30: Gina, Week Six - A-
1x31: Laura, Week Seven - B
1x32: Alex, Week Seven - B-
1x33: Sophie, Week Seven - B
1x34: Jake and Amy, Week Seven: B+

SUPERNATURAL

3x01: The Magnificent Seven - B-
3x02: The Kids Are Alright - B
3x03: Bad Day at Black Rock - B+
3x04: Sin City - C+
3x05: Bedtime Stories - B-
3x06: Red Sky at Morning - B-
3x07: Fresh Blood - B
3x08: A Very Supernatural Christmas - B-
3x09: Malleus Maleficarum - B+
3x10: Dream a Little Dream of Me - C+
3x11: Mystery Spot - A
3x12: Jus In Bello - B+

LOST

4x01: The Beginning of the End - B-
4x02: Confirmed Dead - B-
4x03: The Economist A-
4x04: Eggtown - B
4x05: The Constant A-
4x06: The Other Woman - C+
4x07: Ji Yeon - B

This message has been edited. Last edited by: Alden,

Adding final grades for "Californication".

Adding grades for "Eli Stone" and "Mad Men".

Adding final grades for "Damages".

bump

Adding final grades for "Cold Case" and "Without a Trace".

Adding final grades for "Gossip Girl"

Adding final grades for "Pushing Daisies" and "ER"

Updated grades.