Since the actor one was started, I thought I'd start the performer one.

List the performer and the performance or the storyline. Here it goes

Nancy Lee Grahn, GH , "Kristina's funeral" VS. Eileen Davidson, Days, "Marlena exposes Kristen's secrets."

Nancy Lee Grahn.

Jackie Zeman, GH, BJ Dies vs. Kristian Alfonso, DOOL, Zach dies.

Jackie Zeman, GH, "BJ Dies"

Cynthia Watros, GL, "Annie on Trial" vs Judith Light, OLTL, "Karen on Trial"

OMG!! Those are two monster performances, two of the best ever but I'll go with

Judith Light

Deidre Hall,"Marlena vs. Kristen in the secret room" VS. Kim Zimmer, "Dolly vs. Reva in secret room." - Two of the best fights ever!!

Zimmer.

Marcy Walker (Eden's Rape - Santa Barbara) vs. Katherine Kelly Lang (Brooke's Rape - The Bold and the Beautiful.)

Katherine Kelly Lang, and it's NOT EVEN CLOSE!

Kim Zimmer, GL, "The Slut of Springfield" vs. Kim Zimmer, GL, "Reva Has Cancer"

"Slut of Springfield"

Erika Slezak,"Viki/Jean and Dorian argue over Victor's death and Viki's molestation, 'Jean' later pushes Dorian down the stairs" VS. Robin Strasser, for the same scene as Slezak.

Funny, GloFish, I almost posted the same scene. I'll go with Strasser, tho, in this one.

Douglass Watson (Mac discovers Iris betrayed him. The episode with Carmen Duncan as Iris.) vs.
Anthony Geary (Luke pulls the plug on Lucky.)

Tony Geary- Luke Pulls The Plug On Lucky

Robert Newman- Josh Crashes Into Shayne's Car vs. Jon Hensley- Luke Comes Out of the Closet

Robert Newman

Melody Thomas Scott as Alcoholic Nikki or Robin Christopher as Alcoholic Skye

Scott.

Zimmer (Reva Pulls the Plug on Richard) vs. Ellen Dolan (Margo Pulls the Plug on Casey)

Zimmer

Allison Sweeney, "Sammi's execution" VS. Trevor St. John, "Todd's execution."

Sweeney (tho to be fair, Deidre Hall's work with Sami in prison elevated this storyline to another level for me.)

Susan Lucci (Bianca's intervention.) vs. Jeanne Cooper (Katherine falls off the wagon for the first time in years.)

Susan Lucci

Ellen Dolan, "Margo's Rape" Vs. Rebecca Herbst, "Elizabeth's rape"

Ellen Dolan.

Maura West (Jack and Carly's Breakup) vs. Sharon Case (Cassie Dies)

Maura West (mainly because I thought Joshua Morrow was MVP there)

Susan Flannery (Stephanie confronts Anne Douglas) vs. Eric Braeden (Victor confronts his dying father)

Eric Braeden--he should have won an Emmy for those scenes

Jess Walton (Jill finds out Katherine is her mother) or Jeanne Cooper (Katherine finds out Jill is her daughter)

Jess Walton...totally blew me away. Cooper "phones it in" sometimes and this was not my favorite storyline, but Walton was riveting as she wept at Liz's feet "I don't want another mother."

Peter Bergman (John's death) vs. Robert S. Woods (Asa's death)

That's an almost impossible one, but I'd have to go with Bergman. Woods did his best work in years with Asa's death, however, I went with Bergman, because I think he's the overall better actor and got to show more depth, anger, despair and deception with John's death.

Brad Maule (GH) - BJ's death vs. Justin Deas (GL) - Jenna's Death.

This message has been edited. Last edited by: Allan,

Jeanne Cooper -Best scenes EVER. Oh and no way did Cooper phone in those scenes. JC was on FIRE from mid 2003-late 2004.

Brad Maule (BJ's Death)

Heather Tom (Victoria slaps Victor over the Diego fiasco) or Sharon Case (Sharon learns that Nick is the father of Phyllis baby)

This message has been edited. Last edited by: MTSRocks,