She's only had a couple of months on B&B and nothing truly substantial yet, so it's got to be Heather on OLTL by default.

Okay, let's see...all right, got one:

Kristian Alfonso (Zack's death, Days) vs. Sharon Case (Cassie's death, Y&R)

Sharon Case by a mile... at least she was able to shed some tears...

Jensen Buchanan on "Another World" Vs. Nancy Lee Grahn on "General Hospital"

quote:

Originally posted by Boidiva02:
Sharon Case by a mile... at least she was able to shed some tears...

Jensen Buchanan on "Another World" Vs. Nancy Lee Grahn on "General Hospital"

NANCY LEE GRAHN

EILEEN DAVIDSON - STUCK IN THE SECRET ROOM
VS TAMARA BRAUN - STUCK IN THE PANIC ROOM

Eileen Davidson...

Alicia Leigh Willis "Courntey is a stripper" Vs. Carrie Shayne "Karen strips at Sonny's club and is addicted to drugs"

Shayne.

Lisa Brown (ATWT - Hank comes out to Iva) vs. Jon Hensley (ATWT - Luke comes out to Holden.)

Hensley

Heather Tom (Y&R, Victoria loses her baby) v.s. Heather Tom (OLTL, Kelly loses her baby)

Tom on Y&R--- even as much as i loved her on OLTL, not much can match her outstanding work on Y&R... even if i felt that her emmy that year belonged to Sarah Brown or Rebecca Herbst.

Marcy Walker in "Liza learns Adam switched the sperm samples" VS. Marcy Walker in "Liza sleeps with Ryan Lavery"

This message has been edited. Last edited by: Boidiva02,

Sperm Samples Switch

Hillary B. Smith "Colin holds Nora prisoner in his hosue" v.s. Catherine Hickland, "Lindsay holds Troy prisoner on a huge wheel"

Hickland

Ty Treadway as Colin McIver VS. Ty Treadway as Troy McIver

Ty Treadway as Troy McIver

Julie Pinson as Eve Lambert v.s. Julie Pinson as Billie Reed

Julie Pinson as Eve Lambert

Julie Pinson as Billie Reed VS. Lisa Rinna as Billie Reed

Tough, because I know Pinson is good, but Lisa Rinna.

Michelle Stafford as Sheila on Y&R vs. Kristian Alfonso as Princess Gina on DAYS

Michelle Stafford any day of the week

Jessica Morris as Jenn Rappaport in "Sam is shot" VS. Natalia Livingston as Emily Bowen Quatermaine Cassidine in "Port Charles Hotel Fire"

Livingston.

Maureen Garrett (GL - Holly is Raped) vs. Lenore Kasdorf (GL - Rita in the House of Mirrors.).

Garrett

Amy Auckland in "Abby's "rape" VS. Kate Collins in "Natalie is raped by Ross Chandler"

Kate Collins.

Victoria Wyndham (Body of Work as Rachel - Another World.) vs. Robin Strasser (Body of Work as Rachel - AW.)

i love Strasser, but Wyndham is a force to be reckoned with and made that character her own... so i pick Wyndham

Robin Christopher (body of work as Skye Chandler Quatermaine on ABC soaps) Vs. Linda Dano (body of work as Greatel "Rea" Cummings on all ABC soaps)

Robin Christopher.

Christie Clark (DAYS - Carrie breaks up Sami and Austin's wedding) vs. Allison Sweeney (DAYS - Same scenes.).

Sweeny

2005 Supporting Actress Emmy Submissions
Robin Christopher (Skye sees the daughter she could never have and the girl convinces her to end her life) vs. Jeanne Cooper (Kay sees the ghost of Rex and Phillip III)

Coope cause i don't remember those scenes of Skye's...

Vanessa Marcil in "The Wire Scene" VS. Tamara Braun "Carly tries escaping from the panic room"