Heather Tom. She could out act Sharon Case even if she had a 100 degree fever and was bleeding internally...

Susan Haskell "Marty's Rape & Trial" Vs. Rebecca Herbst "Elizabeth's Rape"

i've decided to sticky this as it seems very popular. i'll close it and open a new thread when it reaches about 40 pages.

Genie Francis "Lucky's Death" or Tony Geary "Lucky's Death"

Genie Francis easily.

Jacklyn Zeamen in "Carly Tells Bobbie she is Caroline" Vs. Cady McClain in "Dixie Tells Tad she gave their baby up for adoption"

quote:

Susan Haskell "Marty's Rape & Trial" Vs. Rebecca Herbst "Elizabeth's Rape"

No question Marty's rape, trial and its aftermath was the most stunningly devestating rape storyline ever put on daytime. Supremely acted, written, and directed.

Susan Haskell by a landslide IMHO.

don't forget to continue the thread... i'll do it for you this time...

Erika Slezak in "Megan's Death" Vs. Genie Francis in "Lucky's Death"

Tough one... Genie

Kelley Hensley-stillborn baby Jennifer Vs. Kelly Monaco- stillborn Baby McCall (Lila)

Monaco, Baby McCall

Judith Light in "Karen Wolek Is A Common Hooker" Vs. Catherine Hickland in "Lindsay Killed Spencer Truman"

Didnt see Judith Light so I have to say Hickland.

Nancy Lee Grahn- Alexis has cancer vs. Kim Zimmer-Reva has cancer.

Zimmer.

Lisa Brown (ATWT) - Iva Reacts to Hank Being Gay vs. Alex Chando - (ATWT) - Maddie Reacts to Noah Being Gay.

Iva, of course. Maddie is no match for Iva.

Jana's brain tumor vs. Carly's lesion

Carly's lesion.

Annie on the Witness Stand (Cynthia Watrous, Guiding Light) vs. Kristen Admits Her Treachery (Eileen Davidson, Days of Our Lives.).

Eileen Davidson


Linda Dano, "Felicia's alcoholism" Vs. Susan Lucci, "Erica's pain pill addiction"

Susan Lucci

Erika Slezak "Viki finds Joey and Dorian in bed" v.s. Jackie Zeman "Bobbie finds Tony and Carly in bed"

Slezak

Tamara Braun-Michael is "dead" vs. Kristian Alfonso- Zach is dead.

Tamara Braun because she at least managed some tears...

Rick Hearst in "The Panic Room Storyline" Vs. Robert Kelker Kelly in "Starvros Is Back From The Dead"

Ric Hearst

Jill Larson, "Opal gives birth in a snowstorm" vs. Tamara Braun, "Carly gives birth after being shot in the head."

Didnt see Opal in the storm, so I'll go with TB giving birth to Morgan.

Jennifer Ferrin-Jen dies vs. Lesli Kay-Felicia dies

Lesli Kay

John Callahan "Edmund finds out Maria is alive" v.s. Michael E. Knight "Tad finds out Dixie is alive"