The Envelope    The Envelope Forum    www.goldderbyforums.com  Hop To Forum Categories  Oscars    Who Should've Won? - Writing
Go
New
Find
Notify
Tools
Reply
  
-star Rating Rate It!  Login/Join 
Even when you were throwing up I could tell that you cared.
Posted
Here's mine:

ADAPTED SCREENPLAY:

Years in which I've seen all of the nominees:

2006 - "Notes on a Scandal"

2002 - "The Pianist"

2001 - "Ghost World"

Years in which I've seen 4/5 nominees:

2005 - "The Constant Gardener"
Missing Link - "Brokeback Mountain"

2000 - "Crouching Tiger, Hidden Dragon"
Missing Link - "Traffic"

Years in which I've seen 3/5 nominees:

2007 - "No Country for Old Men"
Missing Links - "Away from Her" & "The Diving Bell and the Butterfly"

2003 - "American Splendor"
Missing Links - "City of God" & "Mystic River"

ORIGINAL SCREENPLAY:

Years in which I've seen all of the nominees:

2006 - "Babel" or "Letters from Iwo Jima"

2004 - "Eternal Sunshine of the Spotless Mind"

1999 - "American Beauty"

Years in which I've seen 4/5 nominees:

2001 - "Amelie"
Missing Link - "Monster's Ball"

Years in which I've seen 3/5 nominees:

2005 - "Good Night, and Good Luck"
Missing Links - "Match Point" & "Syriana"

2000 - "Almost Famous"
Missing Links - "Gladiator" & "You Can Count on Me"

1997 - "Good Will Hunting"
Missing Links - "Deconstructing Harry" & "The Full Monty"

1995 - "Toy Story"
Missing Links - "Nixon" & "The Usual Suspects"

1994 - "Heavenly Creatures"
Missing Links - "Four Weddings and a Funeral" & "Red"

Random thoughts: Looking through the backlog of writing nominees, it is pretty surprising what was nominated - "Beverly Hills Cop", "Splash", "WarGames"? O-kay...
 
Posts: 1874 | Location: Norwich, VT | Registered: October 12, 2005Reply With QuoteEdit or Delete MessageReport This Post
FYC: The Dark Knight
To sweep this award season.
Posted Hide Post
Original Screenplay
2000: Almost Famous - Cameron Crowe
2001: Memento - Christopher Nolan and Jonathan Nolan
2002: Far from Heaven - Todd Haynes
2003: Lost in Translation - Sofia Coppola
2004: The Incredibles - Brad Bird
2005: Crash - Paul Haggis and Bobby Moresco
2006: Little Miss Sunshine - Michael Arndt
2007: Juno - Diablo Cody

Adapted Screenplay
2000: Traffic - Stephen Gaghan from the teleplay Traffik by Simon Moore
2001: Beautiful Mind - Akiva Goldsman from the biography by Sylvia Nasar
2002: The Pianist - Ronald Harwood from the book by Władysław Szpilman
2003: Mystic River - Brian Helgeland from the novel by Dennis Lehane
2004: Million Dollar Baby - Paul Haggis from Rope Burns: Stories from the Corner by F.X. Toole
2005: Brokeback Mountain - Larry McMurtry and Diana Ossana from the short story by E. Annie Proulx
2006: Notes on a Scandal - Patrick Marber from the novel by Zoë Heller
2007: Atonement - Christopher Hampton from the novel by Ian McEwan


FYC: 2008 Primetime Emmys
Damages. 30 Rock. A Raisin in the Sun. The Colbert Report (and for Writing Team). Gabriel Byrne. Steve Carell. Paul Giamatti. Glenn Close. Tina Fey. Catherine Keener. Željko Ivanek. Neil Patrick Harris. Stephen Dillane. Rachel Griffiths. Vanessa Williams. Audra McDonald. Kathy Griffin: Straight To Hell. Stephen Colbert. Allen Coulter. Barry Sonnenfeld. Todd A. Kessler, Glenn Kessler, & Daniel Zelman. Bryan Fuller. Tom Hooper. Ricky Gervais & Stephen Merchant. Jim Hoskinson. Glynn Turman. Will Arnett. Ellen Burstyn. Elaine Stritch. Autism: The Musical. Deadliest Catch. Dirty Jobs. King of the Hill. Family Guy ("Blue Harvest").
 
Posts: 2276 | Location: New York/California | Registered: September 30, 2006Reply With QuoteEdit or Delete MessageReport This Post
Posted Hide Post
I always find the writing categories difficult because I end up being passionate about more than one of the nominee's!

2007
Original - The Savages
Adapted - No Country For Old Men

2006
Original - ARGHHH! Little Miss Sunshine or Letters From Iwo Jima both amazing pieces of writing!
Adapted - Little Children

2005
Original - Crash
Adapted - Brokeback Mountain

2004
Original - Eternal Sunshine of the Spotless Mind
Adapted - Million Dollar Baby

2003
Original - Lost In Translation
Adapted - City of God

2002
Original - Yu Tu Mama Tambien
Adapted - Adaptation

2001
Original - THIS YEAR HAS AMAZING WRITING! Gosford Park/The Royal Tenembaums/Amelie
Adapted - A Beautiful Mind

2000
Adapted - Traffic
Original - Almost Famous

This message has been edited. Last edited by: presidentmerkinmuffley,
 
Posts: 1272 | Location: Lost In England | Registered: December 26, 2003Reply With QuoteEdit or Delete MessageReport This Post
Even when you were throwing up I could tell that you cared.
Posted Hide Post
2001 was a great year. IMO, both "Mulholland Dr." and "Hedwig and the Angry Inch" should've been nominated as well.
 
Posts: 1874 | Location: Norwich, VT | Registered: October 12, 2005Reply With QuoteEdit or Delete MessageReport This Post
do androids dream of electric sheep?
Posted Hide Post
I'll have a go at this but I looked over the nominees and it's very difficult for me to choose just one:

2007-
Adapted: All pretty good...The Diving Bell and The Butterfly
Original: Michael Clayton; all great writing save ONE perplexing crap-fest screenplay

2006-
A: A three-way tie with Notes on a Scandal, Children of Men, and Little Children
O: Something wonderful about all the nominees, but I'll say Pan's Labyrinth

2005-
A: All great, but Brokeback Mountain for the win!
O: Syriana

2004-
A: Sideways
O: whoa...ESOTSM; a great line-up

2003-
A: I liked all of these, but I'll say City of God
O: The Barbarian Invasions

2002-
A: Adaptation, with About a Boy and The Pianist close seconds
O: A tie with Talk to Her and Y Tu Mama Tambien

2001-
A: The Lord of The Rings, with Ghost World, In The Bedroom, Shrek close seconds
O: Memento

2000-
A: Wow; I love all of these screenplays...five-way tie
O: hmm; all worthy except for Gladiator

1999-
A: The Talented Mr Ripley
O: gach...all good in such diff ways...

1998-
A: A Simple Plan, with Gods and Monsters close
O: whoa...Shakespeare In Love

1997-
A: Easy, LA Confidential
O: Boogie Nights

1996-
A: Sling Blade
O: Fargo, with props to Secrets and Lies, Shine, and Lone Star

1995-
A: Babe
O: The Usual Suspects

1994-
A: wow...ok, Forrest Gump, cuz he knows what love is
O: Pulp Fiction in what I think was a great year

1993-
A: Schindler's Lost er, List Lol
O: The Piano

1992-
A: The Player
O: The Crying Game, with props to the others

1991-
A: The Silence of the Lambs
O: wow! What a great line-up..Boyz N the Hood

1990-
A: Good Fellas, with The Grifters RU
O: Avalon

1989-
A: Driving Miss Daisy
O: arrgh...Sex, Lies, and Videotape, with kudos also to all of the other nominees

1988-
A: Blech...Gorillas in The Mist, for the gorillas...
O: Running On Empty, but all very good

1987-
A: Full Metal Jacket
O: all good...Broadcast News

1986-
A: Stand By Me
O: Hannah and Her Sisters, with kudos to the others

1985-
A: arrgh...
O: Brazil!

1984-
A: Amadeus, with The Killing Fields and Passage to India very close
O: sheesh....

1983-
A: The Dresser
O: The Big Chill

1982-
A: a great year...Sophie's Choice
O: Tootsie

1981-
A: Ragtime
O: whoa....Reds

1980-
A: Breaker Morant
O: Melvin and Howard, with props to My American Cousin

1979-
A: arrgh...La Cage aux Folles
O: all great!..for the, "you're such a tease" line with Death, All That Jazz

1978-
A: California Suite
O: The Deer Hunter

1977-
A: Julia
O: Annie Hall in a cake walk

1976-
A: All The President's Men, with props to Bound for Glory and Casanova
O: Network in a landslide, with kudos to Seven Beauties

1975-
A: One Flew Over the Cuckoo's Nest
O: Amarcord

1974-
A: The Godfather 2
O: Chinatown!; but all actually good

1973-
A: The Exorcist
O: A terrific line-up where I cant pick just one or even two or three

1972-
A: The Godfather
O: The Candidate

1971-
A: A Clockwork Orange! with props to The Last Picture Show
O: Another terrific line-up, but I'll go with Paddy Chayefsky

1970-
A: Lovers and Other Strangers, but all good in wildly diff ways
O: Five Easy Pieces

1969-
A: Arrgh! ties
O: gach!
This year had tons of parity in writing where I could make a case for all ten of these films

1968-
A: The Lion in Winter; The Odd Couple RU
O: 2001: A Space Odyssey (hurrahs to Stanley Kubrick and Arthur C Clarke)

1967-
A: five-way tie
O: Bonnie and Clyde

1966-
A: whoa...all great
O: A Man and a Woman

1965-
A: Another great year...Doctor Zivago, with props to A Thousand Clowns
O: Darling; The Umbrellas of Cherbourg RU

1964-
A: Dr. Strangelove!
O: A Hard Day's Night (why not?)

1963-
A: Hud
O: 8 1/2

1962-
A: wow...what a year...
O: Through a Glass Darkly

1961-
A: Judgement at Nuremberg
O: For William Inge and Zohra Lampert, I'll say Splendor in The Grass...

I cant type anymore. I'll probably finish up later.

1960-
A: Inherit the Wind
O: The Apartment

1959-
A: Anatomy of a Murder, with props to three of the other winner/nominees
O: Gach...tie with The 400 Blows and North by Northwest

1958-
A: Great year...Separate Tables
O: The Defiant Ones

1957-
A: The Bridge on The River Kwai, with props to all the other nominees
O: Designing Woman

1956-
A: gach...Giant
O: The Red Balloon in a close one

1955-
Marty,..hmm, have not seen The Sheep Has Five Legs; props also to Blackboard Jungle, East of Eden, and Bad Day at Black Rock

1954-
such a great year; like I said, one of my favorite years...
On the Waterfront, with kudos to Sabrina, Rear Window, and the Caine Mutiny

1953-
Props to Roman Holiday, Shane, Hondo, and From Here to Eternity

1952-
Ditto to The Bad and The Beautiful, Lavender Hill Mob, and esp The Quiet Man

1951-
wow; all great..personal fave, African Queen.

I'll stop just before Sunset Blvd.

This message has been edited. Last edited by: babypook,
 
Posts: 5503 | Location: canada | Registered: December 22, 2005Reply With QuoteEdit or Delete MessageReport This Post
Neophyte's serendipity
Posted Hide Post
My choices:

1977:
O: Annie Hall
A: Julia

1978:
O: The Deer Hunter
A: California Suite

1979:
O: Manhattan
A: Kramer vs. Kramer

1980:
O: Fame
A: Ordinary People/Coal Miner's Daughter

1981:
O: Reds
A: no choice

1982:
O: ET
A: wow. Sophie's Choice

1983:
O: no choice
A:

1984:
O: Places in the Heart
A: Terms of Endearment

1985:
O: no choice
A: Out of Africa

1986:
O: Hannah and Her Sisters
A: Children fo a Lesser God

1987:
O: Broadcast News
A: Fatal Attraction

1988:
O: Rain Man
A: all good

1989:
O: Sex, Lies and Videotape
A: Driving Miss Daisy

1990:
O: Ghost
A: Goodfellas

1991
O: Thelma and Louise
A: Silence of the Lambs

1992:
O: The Crying Game
A: Howards End

1993:
O: Philadelphia (props to The Piano)
A: Schindler's List

1994:
O: Pulp Fiction
A: The Shwashank Redemption

1995:
O:Mighty Aphrodite
A: Sense and Sensibility

1996:
O: Fargo
A: The English Patient

1997:
O: Boogie Nights
A: LA Confidential

1998:
O: Shakespeare in Love (The Truman Show close second)
A:: Gods and Monsters

1999:
O: American Beauty (BJM second)
A: three way tie

2000:
O: Billy Elliott
A: Wow. Uhm Traffic (CHocolat in 2nd place)

2001:
O: Amelie (Gosford Park second)
A: In the Bedroom

2002:
O: Y Tu Mama Tambien
A: The Hours

2003:
O: Lost in Translation
A: LOTR: ROTK

2004:
O: Eternal Sunshine of the Spotless MInd
A: Sideways

2005:
O: Match Point
A: Brokeback Mountain

2006:
O: Little Miss Sunshine
A: Notes on a Scandal

2007:
O: Michael Clayton
A: No Country for Old Men


FYC EMMY VOTERS!!!

Please consider the following performances:

Kristin Chenoweth (Pushing Daisies)
Julia Louis Dreyfus (New Adventures of Old Christine)
Steve Carell (The Office)
Hugh Laurie (House)
Kyra Sedgwick (The Closer)
Neil Patrick Harris (How I Met Your Mother)
 
Posts: 8834 | Location: Manila | Registered: August 19, 2006Reply With QuoteEdit or Delete MessageReport This Post
 Previous Topic | Next Topic powered by eve community  
 

The Envelope    The Envelope Forum    www.goldderbyforums.com  Hop To Forum Categories  Oscars    Who Should've Won? - Writing

© Los Angeles Times 2007

Gold Derby
The Dish Rag
Extended Play